The DMK Years : Ascent, Descent, Survival


Name :  The DMK years : Ascent, Descent , Survival
Author :  R.Kannan
    Year of Publication : 2024
    Genre : Non-fiction, Politics, History
    Rating : ** 1/2 ( Two and a half stars out of 5)

The author needs to be lauded for his sweeping ambition of encapsulating the work of an era in nearly 500 odd pages. Every significant event associated with the history of DMK is covered. To avoid being called hagiographic, the book errs by moving to the other extreme - all it's criticisms of DMK are detailed while the deserved praise is rushed. The author eschews scholarship for chronological recollections and much needed analyses go missing. DMK is a remarkable institution and Kannan does not even come close to doing justice to it.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Saffron Storm

Image
Name : The Saffron Storm Author : Saba Naqvi     Year of Publication : 2024     Genre : Non - Fiction, Politics     Rating : *** ( Three stars out of 5) The author is a journalist and a fellow-traveller who has chronicled the rise and fall (and rise) of BJP over the past 3 decades. That the author is a Muslim adds spice. The author steers clear of ideological judgements and opinionated writing. Her forte is reportage and she clearly sticks to that. The best portions cover the day-to-day functioning of the first ever non-Congress coalition government to have completed a full term. The most interesting anecdote relates to Vajpayee's strategy on handling USA's request to mobilise Indian troops for it's operations in Iraq.  A good read to compare and contrast the times of Vajpayee and Modi.
Read more

Indian Summers

Image
  Name : Indian Summers Author : John Wright     Year of Publication : 2006     Genre : Non - Fiction, Cricket     Rating : ** 1/2  ( Two and a half stars out of 5) Considering the author coached the Indian cricket team during it's most transformative phase, the expectations from the book are high. The sense of humour is a particular highlight but otherwise, John Wright's bemused fascination with India and it's ways make for merely familiar reading. A separate chapter on icons like Ganguly, Sachin and Dravid was warranted but Wright gets content with concise descriptions on clashes and discussions. John Wright's tenure means much more to Indian fans than what is described in the book but at best, the book remains an outsider's account - engaging but aloof.
Read more

Pitchside

Image
  Name : Pitchside : My life in Indian Cricket Authors : Amrit Mathur     Year of Publication : 2023     Genre : Non - Fiction, Cricket     Rating : ** * ( Three stars out of 5) Amrit Mathur, the ultimate insider of Indian cricket who has played multiple roles from administrator to first-class umpire, pens an engaging memoir that covers crucial episodes of Indian cricket such as Natwest 2002, Pakistan 2004, World Cup 2003, IPL, among others. What makes this particular memoir stand out is that the author does not restrict itself to on-field action - it captures the routines before matches, the joyous banter in team lunches, the superstitions which supposedly help the team win etc. Imran Khan's public persona is available for consumption in various other tomes but nothing can match the parent Khan in the pages of this book who is trying to make his kids sleep before making small talk with guests who have come for dinner.
Read more